GAH! The ever-growing BACKLOG!! How do we prioritize what we PLAY?!

Michael Herman asks
I have the toughest time picking what game to play next out of my ever-growing backlog. How do you guys prioritize your backlogs and pick which game comes next? Also, how do you manage to stick with that game before bouncing on to the next in the queue?

FOLLOW US
Kinsey: https://www.youtube.com/kinseyburke
John Riggs: https://www.youtube.com/riggstalgic
John Hancock: https://www.youtube.com/swlovinist
Kelsey: https://www.youtube.com/kelseylewin
Reggie: https://www.youtube.com/icon770
DMP: http://www.youtube.com/drunkenmasterpaul